97 thoughts on “Ian Somerhalder vs. Stephen Amell: Who Should Play 50 Shades of Grey’s Leading Man? Vote Now! | E! Online”

  2. I am voting for ian…he is not overly muscled and has that come F___ me look and I will take you on the wild side..super hot and young enough to play the part..remember ladies Christian grey is only 27

  4. I pick Ian somerhalder, he is who I picterd when I read the books, he has the wild, sexy, look to him, plues he is the age range because grey is only 27, plues grey has no tattoos!! 🙂

    • Stephen’s tattoos are just for “Arrow”, they’re not real 🙂 He’s also a few years younger than Ian.

  22. Its easy to be taken by physicality but who has the acting chops to fill the part? I think that Ian is a good choice, Ive not watched ‘Diaries’ for some time but he is quite striking, Can make his eyes gray I spose ,with contacts, hair with a bit of dye and his body is tight but not over-done…nice in my opinion.. I can see him doing it… but the real question is HOW are they going to do it… I cant see it doing the books any justice without going fairly whole-hog… Is anyone else thinking that this could be a fantastic cross-over between grown-up movie and porn? Hard-core porn as such is fake as shit but if this was done really well with a decent budget it could be a classic really… if it were done fully R18 and a LOT more classy than mainstream porn, I would buy it EVERY time…

  24. No matter who you play IAN against. Ian will win every time!!!!! Proven fact!! Ian has been in all POLLS and he has always been first. Ian Somerhalder is Christian Grey !! 😉

  30. if i had to choose between these 2 – Ian….but i dont really want either of them to play Christian! LOL

  31. I always pictures Channing Tatum however Stephen Amell is just as HOTT!…… So therefore he gets my vote!

  34. Stephen Amell! He has the body, the height, the charisma. Plus, he’s closer to Christian’s age than Ian.

  36. Jessie Pavelka is my first choice…..Stephen Amell is a GREAT second choice for me. BUT…..between Stephan & Ian………..DEFINITELY STEPHEN AMELL!!!!

  38. Definitely Stephen, he has this dark and mystery look to him! And a height and body to go with it! Perfect CG material!

  43. Ian Ian you’re so fine, you’re so fine you blow my mind! Ian is the best choice. His eyes burn right through your soul. #Perfect #ChristianGrey

Leave a reply to Anonymous x